Lacking focus he may be, but she has to admit, when he puts it that way, it does seem logical. She doesn't even think to question the apparent existence of literal angels and demons, heaven and hell. She comes from a world with abnormals. By now, she thinks, it seems only natural.

"Well, it would make the idea rather less attractive, wouldn't it?" She's severely cursing the lack of proper medical supplies right now. Even something as simple as being able to find or grow natural remedies would be a tremendous help, particularly if they're going to insist on continually bringing in the ill and injured or tormenting them all in ways that threaten their health. Then again, that's probably the point. "I assume you didn't succeed?"

Otherwise, from what she's gathering, he'd already be dead by now.