To be sure, he's dressed a little ridiculously, even by modern standards. Hook was willing to give up his heavy duster for date night, but he couldn't quite get away from leather. He could be far worse as appearance goes, his suitcase is armed with his older things that downright scream 17th century pirate (which is why he's been trying to avoid them).

The question is. . . well, complicated. Some of those from Storybrooke are open about what and who they are, Hook isn't. And really, he doesn't entirely remember where he was born, though that's more revealing than he cares to share. "I was in Maine, before I was here." Close enough.